Can You Really Make Money with Telegram Signals?
15th Jul 2025Telegram has become a hub for thousands of trading signal groups promising quick profits, insider tips, and so-called “VIP trades.” For many new traders, joining a Telegram channel feels like a shortcut to success. But here’s the real question: Can you actually make money with Telegram signals?
In this article, we take a realistic, no-hype look at how Telegram trading signals work, their common pitfalls, and whether they can truly deliver consistent profits, especially compared to automated copy trading platforms like SMARTT.
What Are Telegram Trading Signals?
Telegram trading signals are trade suggestions shared via Telegram groups or channels. These signals usually include:
• Asset (e.g., XAU/USD or EUR/USD)
• Entry price
• Take profit and stop loss
• Sometimes, timeframes or chart screenshots
They’re typically provided by individuals or teams claiming to have trading expertise, and they may offer both free and paid (VIP) channels.
Many traders join these channels hoping to get easy wins without learning technical analysis. But the reality is more complicated.
Pros of Telegram Trading Signals
There are a few reasons why Telegram signals are popular:
1. Accessibility
Anyone with a smartphone can subscribe to channels and receive signals instantly, often for free.
2. Speed
Most signals are shared in real-time, allowing users to quickly jump into trades if they’re watching closely.
3. Community and Hype
Telegram groups often create a sense of energy and momentum, perfect for social traders who enjoy the vibe of group activity.
But while these benefits are tempting, they come with some serious risks.
The Problems With Relying on Telegram Signals
1. Lack of Transparency
Most Telegram signal providers don’t show verified performance records. Win rates are often exaggerated, and past losses are hidden.
2. No Risk Management for You
Unlike automated platforms, Telegram signals don't enforce stop-loss discipline or position sizing. It's up to you to enter trades correctly, manage risk, and exit at the right time.
3. Human Error and Delays
You have to manually execute trades, and in volatile markets, even a few seconds of delay can ruin your entry.
4. Overtrading and Signal Spam
Many channels flood users with 10+ signals a day. This leads to emotional overtrading, scattered focus, and high losses.
5. No Regulation or Oversight
Telegram signal providers are usually unlicensed individuals. There’s no regulation, customer protection, or quality control.
What the Numbers Say
Let’s say a Telegram channel advertises an 80%-win rate. If you enter 50 trades based on their signals:
• If they actually win 40 and lose 10, you might think you’re doing well.
• But without a fixed risk/reward, even one bad trade with high leverage can wipe out weeks of small gains.
• Most users don’t follow signals exactly due to delay or confusion, leading to even worse outcomes.
And since most groups don’t publish loss data, the performance you see is often cherry-picked.
Safer Alternatives: Automated and Transparent Copy Trading
If your goal is to make consistent income, relying on random signal messages is risky. A better approach is to use automated copy trading platforms where:
• Traders are verified by real performance data
• Trades are executed automatically — no manual input needed
• Risk management tools (e.g., stop-loss caps) are built into the system
• You can track each trader’s monthly returns, drawdown, and volatility
Platforms like SMARTT connect you with over 200 high-performing traders whose strategies are available for copying in real time. You can customize your risk settings, split capital across multiple traders, and even simulate outcomes before committing funds.
👉 Learn more on the Copy Trading page.
SMARTT vs Telegram Signals – Why It’s Not Even Close
Feature |
Telegram Signals |
SMARTT Copy Trading |
Automation |
❌ Manual |
✅ Fully automated |
Risk Management |
❌ Up to user |
✅ Built-in protection |
Verified Performance |
❌ Rare or fake |
✅ Transparent dashboards |
Emotion-Free Trading |
❌ Highly emotional |
✅ Rules-based execution |
Broker Integration |
❌ None |
✅ Regulated brokers like FBS and Exness |
Passive Income Possibility |
❌ Unlikely |
✅ Designed for long-term growth |
👉 For full broker details, check the Broker Licenses page.
Final Thoughts
So, can you really make money with Telegram signals?
Sometimes, but inconsistently, and with a high risk of loss due to manual execution, lack of data, and poor risk control.
If you’re serious about turning trading into a reliable source of income, you need a system that combines data transparency, automation, and smart risk controls — not random messages in a chat app.
SMARTT offers a scalable, trustworthy solution that eliminates the guesswork of Telegram signals, making it ideal for both new and intermediate traders.