SmartT vs 3Commas (2025) | AI Copy Trading for Forex vs Crypto
SmartT and 3Commas both automate decisions—but they’re built for different worlds. SmartT is an AI copy trading platform for forex (and gold/indices/crypto via MT4/MT5 brokers) that keeps funds in your own broker account and overlays risk filters (AI Advisor, Market Sentiment, Rate Guard 1:2 on Elite). 3Commas is a crypto-focused automation suite (bots, DCA, grid, signals). If you trade currencies (and XAUUSD) with expert advisers or want risk-first copy trading, SmartT aligns with that DNA; if you build bot strategies on crypto exchanges, 3Commas feels native.
Safety and fit depend on asset class. Forex and gold trading live in MT4/MT5 ecosystems with precise lot-sizing, margin, and broker-based execution. Crypto is exchange-native with different liquidity rhythms, funding fees, and 24/7 volatility. Our comparison focuses on:
- Capital custody: where your funds sit and how orders are routed.
- Risk guardrails: AI filters, sentiment gates, R:R enforcement, and daily loss caps.
- Strategy fit: copy trading vs build-your-own bot; expert adviser workflows vs exchange bots.
- Gold trading (XAUUSD): volatility handling and discipline.
- Beginner readiness: setup ease, default safety, and transparency.
| Dimension | SmartT (Forex-first AI Copy Trading) | 3Commas (Crypto Automation) |
|---|---|---|
| Capital custody | Funds remain in your MT4/MT5 broker account; SmartT automates with your risk settings. | Funds stay on crypto exchanges you connect (API); bot executes on-exchange. |
| Risk layer | AI Advisor (Pro/Elite), Market Sentiment (Pro/Elite), Rate Guard 1:2 (Elite), daily caps, trader limits. | Rules-based bot controls (DCA/grid/TP/SL); no identical AI guard focused on copy-trade filtering. |
| Copy trading | Core feature: follow top traders; automation + AI risk screens. | Primary focus is bot strategy building/signals; copy-trade analogs vary by marketplace integrations. |
| Gold trading (XAUUSD) | Supported via brokers; AI filters help during spikes; portfolio R:R discipline. | Not native (crypto exchanges). Gold exposure would be indirect, if at all. |
| EA / forex bot fit | Designed for MT4/MT5; can run alongside an expert adviser with separated risk budgets. | EA concept doesn’t apply; instead, exchange bots and signals are the norm. |
| Beginner experience | Plug-and-play copy trading; risk-first defaults; funds remain at your broker. | Requires grasp of crypto exchange mechanics, bot parameters, and 24/7 risk. |
| Plans (30 days) | Basic $15 (0 traders), Standard $30 (2), Pro $90 (8, AI/Sentiment), Elite $150 (12, +Rate Guard). | Pricing varies by plan/exchange features; compare per exchange/bot limits. |
SMARTT merges copy trading with risk-first automation. You pick traders; the system executes with your risk caps while three controls shape quality:
- AI Advisor (Pro/Elite): blocks weak setups before execution.
- Market Sentiment (Pro/Elite): avoids trades moving against broader direction.
- Rate Guard (Elite): enforces a 1:2 minimum risk-to-reward—nudging expectancy upward.
Plans are monthly (30 days): from $15 Basic up to $150 Elite; trader limits are 0/2/8/12. Because capital stays in your own broker account, you retain custody and can also run an expert adviser or a personal forex bot alongside SmartT—just keep risks separated.
3Commas is a crypto-native automation layer: connect your exchange accounts via API and build DCA/grid/strategy bots, or consume signals. For advanced crypto users, this flexibility is powerful. But you must manage 24/7 volatility, funding rates, exchange risk, and bot parameter drift. For traditional copy trading or gold trading, 3Commas is not the natural home base.
- Choose SmartT if you want best copy trading discipline for forex and gold trading, broker-custodied funds, and AI guardrails that filter weak trades and enforce healthier R:R.
- Choose 3Commas if your priority is building crypto bots on exchanges, tweaking parameters, and living in a 24/7 market loop.
- Use both—carefully if you are multi-asset: keep separate capital, rules, and expectations for FX vs crypto.
- Risk per trade small (0.25–1%); enforce a daily loss cap.
- Diversify providers (SmartT) or strategies (3Commas) to avoid correlation traps.
- Prefer providers/bots with positive average R:R and controlled drawdowns; avoid martingale/grid rescue behavior.
- For gold trading, use tighter exposure limits than on majors; news blackout windows help.
- Review weekly; retire underperformers quickly—don’t average down on failing logic.
SMARTT blends copy trading with AI Advisor, Market Sentiment, and (Elite) Rate Guard 1:2. Plans (30 days): from $15 Basic, $30 Standard, $90 Pro, $150 Elite; trader limits 0/2/8/12. Your capital stays in your own MT4/MT5 broker account.
FAQs
Is SmartT only for forex?
SmartT is forex-first (MT4/MT5) and supports assets your broker lists—often including gold (XAUUSD) and sometimes crypto/indices.
Does SmartT hold my funds?
No. Your capital stays in your own broker account; SmartT automates execution under your risk settings.
Can I run an expert adviser with SmartT?
Yes. Keep risk budgets separate and avoid overlapping signals; SmartT is designed to coexist with MT4/MT5 EAs.
Is 3Commas suitable for gold trading?
3Commas is crypto-native; gold trading is not an exchange-native instrument there. Use SmartT with brokers for XAUUSD.
Which is safer in 2025: SmartT or 3Commas?
For forex and gold, SmartT offers integrated AI guardrails and broker-custodied funds. For crypto bots, 3Commas is strong—just manage 24/7 exchange risk carefully.
Final note: For the most accurate and up-to-date details (features, fees, supported assets, availability), please visit each platform’s official website.
Written by